Lok Sabha polls 2014: Ladakh keeps analysts busy with no clear winner here
Over the next one week, both Congress vice-president Rahul and BJP leader Gadkari are scheduled to campaign in Ladakh, which goes to polls on May 7.
Over the next one week, both Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi and BJP leader Nitin Gadkari are scheduled to campaign in Ladakh, which goes to polls on May 7. The region has fielded four candidates, representing 159,631 voters spread across the desert districts of Leh and Kargil.
Gandhi is flying in on Tuesday to campaign for Tsering Samphel. Gadkari follows on May 4 for Thupstan Chhewang, the most senior politician in the fray. But the two Buddhist are not alone. They have two Shia Muslims—Ghulam Raza and Syed Qasim Sabri, from Kargil, 235 km from Leh—in the ring too.
Under the Congress-National Conference coalition arrangement, Ladakh was given to Congress. But the decision makers ignored the reality that Leh and Kargil have fought pitched battles to retain the Lok Sabha seat. Given the narrow differences between voters of the two districts, it has always been tricky to contest and win. So far, the Congress has represented it six times, the NC twice and independents thrice.
The two districts appear to have evolved an interesting modus operandi to flout party dictates. If a party picks a candidate from Leh, Kargil reacts and vice versa. Leh did it once and Kargil twice. In 2009, Kargil’s independent candidate Ghulam Hassan Khan (who later joined NC), defeated Congress’ P Namgyal by a narrow margin of just 3,600 votes.
History seems to be repeating itself. Peeved over the coalition fielding a Buddhist, Kargil Congress asked its former district president and lawmaker Ghulam Raza to resign and contest independently. Kargil’s anti-Congress lobby took it as party’s strategy to reduce the impact of Muslim vote and make Samphel win. They fielded another candidate, Agha Syed Qasim Sabri.
In Kargil, political decisions are mostly taken by two religious institutions: the Khomanie Trust and the Islamia School. The Khomanie Trust is a sort of neo-liberal thought that is currently dominated by the Congress, but the all-powerful Islamia School is controlled by the Aghas, the town’s most influential clan. That makes Raza a Lilliput and Sabri a candidate to be reckoned with because of Aghas’ backing.
Analysts say that Leh faces a similar situation. After Congress fielded its district president, T Samphel, BJP’s Thupstan Chhewang joined the fray. Given the influence the two candidates have, Buddhist vote is divided.
"Voter is confused because both are equally good," said Dorjey Wangchuk, an official. "Thupstan, however, is enjoying a better standing than Samphal because he has been there for a long time; he commands respect and has some contribution as well."
Scion of Leh’s Raja family that ruled the region for the long time, Thupstan’s wife Sarla is still considered the Queen of Ladakh. Thupstan shot into prominence when, as head of the Ladakh Buddhist Association (LBA), he spearheaded a communal agitation that eventually led to the creation of Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council (LAHDC) in 1995. He headed the Council till he was elected to Parliament in 2004. Then, he was contesting as a candidate of Ladakh Union Territory Front (LUTF).
Thupstan’s politics revolve around converting Ladakh into a Union territory and he has managed to get this slogan back on the street. Key observers say it was a mistake on the part of Congress.
"It was initially Congress that announced they will get UT to Ladakh," political activist Feroz Ahmad, said. "The announcement was fiercely reacted to by PCC chief Prof Saif ud Din Soz, saying it was not part of the Congress manifesto. Then NC and PDP reacted fiercely to it."
The issue then landed in BJP’s lap with Thupstan, the person who had raised the demand first, cashing in on it.
Analysts say that with the UT issue lost to the BJP, Congress is now exploiting the introduction of Sindhu Darshan, a yearly festival that a BJP-led Delhi government had introduced in October 1997 and which was later taken up by LK Advani as deputy prime minister. Congress sees the festival as BJP’s idea of impacting Tibetan culture.
However, some analysts think that the key to any candidate’s victory lies neither in Leh nor in Kargil. It is the remote Buddhist enclave of Zanskar that is likely to upset everyone’s calculation. The enclave has 8,000 votes, which, if polled to a single candidate will decide the verdict. "But that is not the case," said Asgar Ali. "If the reports we are getting in Kargil are correct, then Zanskar is polling for both the Buddhists and even a part of it is coming to Islamia School."
While it is premature to forecast the poll outcome, if Modi takes Ladakh, it will be a Himalayan victory.