The Economic Times
English EditionEnglish Editionहिन्दीગુજરાતી
| E-Paper

    How Indian Americans have failed to make a strong impact on US mainstream culture


    In movies, music, and theatre, the Indian-American immigrant experience is still a long way from making an impact in mainstream popular entertainment.

    It is quite ironic that Bollywood’s crossover star Priyanka Chopra was chosen for TV drama thriller Quantico, instead of an Indian-American actor. But even such moments are few and far between
    Come August, the India Day Parade will wind its way down New York City. The commemoration of India’s Independence Day is also a salute of sorts to the achievements of Indians in the US. Like every year, it is most likely to have the ambience of an Indian wedding — colourful ethnic costumes and Bollywood song-and-dance sequences. But the parade, held in NYC since 1981, will also highlight that it is still not a big draw for non-Indian New Yorkers to connect with Indian culture. In short, it will be another lost opportunity to display India’s soft power in the heart of the US.

    The community has done well in academia and also in the corporate world. Prominent Indian-American writer Chitra Divakaruni sees writers who are choosing the immigrant experience genre getting recognised. “Indian-American writers such as late Bharati Mukherjee, Deepak Chopra, Jhumpa Lahiri, myself, Mindy Kaling and Akhil Sharma have won prizes and have been on bestseller lists. Our books are taught in colleges and universities and are book-club favourites. So I would say we are making a distinct mark on American society.” But the fact remains that these are more exception that the rule. The India diaspora has not been able to make a larger impact on the psyche of the US mainstream culture, when compared with, say, the Chinese Americans.

    m night shyamalanAgencies
    Manoj “Night” Shyamalan has seen some success in Hollywood. But even he has not explored Indian themes, probably because of the lack of its acceptance in American pop culture

    Language Barrier
    Students in American higher education institutions looking to study foreign languages have little or no options from India. There are few offerings of Hindi, Urdu or Sanskrit and even fewer of languages such as Bengali and Tamil. But Chinese and Japanese are among the top 10 foreign languages Americans learn in schools and colleges. In movies, music, and theatre, the Indian-American immigrant experience is still a long way from making an impact in mainstream popular entertainment. It is, in fact, quite ironic that the meatiest role in American TV so far was bagged not by an Indian-American actor but by Bollywood’s crossover star, Priyanka Chopra, in TV drama thriller Quantico. But even such moments are few and far between.

    Swati Ali, a New York-based independent film-maker, says the underlying differences in culture between the two countries could be the reason for the poor Indian representation. “Internationally, after Hollywood, India probably has the biggest footprint in cinema. However, we have still not been able to capture the imagination of America, like we have in other countries. The reason for this could be a dramatic difference in culture and the tone/style of movies in both countries. The most common stereotype with regard to the average Indian American is that he/she is a techie.”

    Mira Nair’s Salaam Bombay!; Slumdog Millionaire and Manoj “Night” Shyamalan have had major success in Hollywood. But such accolades and recognition continue to be rare for films with Indian themes. Even Shyamalan has not explored Indian themes.

    Arts & Entertainment
    Vishakha Desai, a scholar of Asian art, who was the president and CEO of the influential Asia Society from 2004 to 2012 and is now an adjunct professor at Columbia University, puts things into perspective: all Asian-Americans suffer from a lack of representation in arts and entertainment in the US. “The first generation of Indian immigrants focused on professional degrees in science, engineering and medicine. Plenty of second generation Indian Americans are exploring more diverse fields, including arts and culture. But like other Asian-Americans, they also suffer from stereotyping of their ethnicity or simply from exclusion.”

    One Asian group that has done comparatively well on this front is the Chinese-American community. There is, of course, an historic advantage. The Chinese started arrived in the US in the 18th Century, while the large wave of Indian immigration began in the early 19th Century, says Aroon Shivdasani, a founding member of the Indo-American Arts Council, a New York city organisation promoting artists of Indian origin in North America. Tradition has remained important for Chinese and Indians, irrespective of their employment and education, she says. However, the basic difference has been that “as part of getting settled, the Chinese popularised their food and festivals wherever they could. Early Indian immigrants concentrated on employment and education, considering the arts an indulgence.”

    aroon shivdasani
    Aroon Shivdasani

    Indian-American immigrants are among the highest per capita earners, and have deep pockets. But they have arguably not encouraged their children to push their heritage through art, music, theatre, dance, film. Arvind Manocha, 46, was an exception. The music lover grew up in Ohio listening to everything from Indian ragas to Beethoven to Queen. Manocha is now president and CEO of Wolf Trap Foundation for the Performing Arts, a non-profit organisation that partners with the US National Park Service to provide concert and performing art facilities in Virginia. This background has helped him grasp cultural nuances. Indian Americans can be more visible in music and arts only if their aspirations are nurtured, he says. “And in our community, it’s very important for the parents to see their children in the arts, than just the children themselves.” Manocha was lucky as his parents supported his career choice. “I have often been the only Indian American in the organisations in which I’ve worked.”

    Arvind Manocha

    In Hollywood
    Farhad Ahmed Dehlvi, a Los Angelesbased cinematographer who was part of the camera crew of The Dark Knight Rises and Life of Pi, says a difference will be felt when more talented people of Indian origin start working not just as actors in Hollywood, but also start getting involved in behind-the-scenes roles. “We still have a long way to go, but I see more diverse voices in Hollywood.”

    But till that happens, Indian Americans in US movies will continue to be the stereotyped Gujaratis, with caricatured accents, running convenience stores, or nerds who work as computer programmers — much like the characters played by Kal Penn in the film series Harold & Kumar or Kunal Nayyar as Dr Raj Koothrappali in the TV series The Big Bang Theory.

    5 Comments on this Story

    R D Vohra901 days ago
    Americans always proud to be BEST in the world. Owner/renter of an office of 10X10 ft dealing in security system while interviewing a candidates states " You are going to have a world class interview". Anyhow, entertainment industry is not filled with enough Indians because of tone of English, though better than Afro-American but they do not understand. Current generation is assimilating in US culture speaking slang language and giving all types of sex scenes or doing porno....Gujrati and south Indian touch to English is still felt.Indians are generally more qualified than local Americans which is also a reason of keeping each other at bay. However things are changing ABCD are adapting Americanism.
    Monoranjan Bezboruah901 days ago
    Much ado about nohing. In due course, we will have all of these and much more. Hard work, perseverence, and love, respect and pride in our heritage are already laying the yellow brick road ahead!
    Rajendra Vitthal Ishi902 days ago
    Very nice article great information thanks
    The Economic Times